Ensuring a loan is a loan (or alone with you**) – part 1

Arguably, in relation to any form of loan arrangement, it is fundamentally important that there are documents confirming the exact terms that apply.

Purely from an asset protection perspective, ignoring wider issues such as the commercial arrangements, estate planning and tax, the importance of documenting loan arrangements in writing cannot be underemphasised.

Similarly, it is critical to consider:

1. Regular repayments, even if only nominal, to ensure that the terms of the agreement remain on foot and acknowledged by the parties. In this regard, as profiled elsewhere in these posts, government legislation can automatically cause loans to become unrecoverable and statute barred.
2. Possibly implementing security arrangements in relation to the loan, for example, by way of mortgage or registering an interest under the PPSR.
3. Ensuring that each party to the loan receives independent legal advice. Particularly in relation to arrangements between family members, the failure to ensure each party receives independent legal advice can cause a loan to become unrecoverable on the basis that a court decides that the loan was in fact a gift.

The requirement for independent advice is arguably the most important aspect in family situations, such as parents lending funds to a child and their spouse.

If the child and spouse have a relationship breakdown it is likely that the funds advanced will be argued to be a gift by the estranged spouse, even if a loan agreement has been signed.

If the amount is treated as a gift it will be an asset of the relationship (not the parents as lenders) and thus unrecoverable by the parents.

** for the trainspotters the title of the post today is riffed from the early 1980’s and The Sunnyboys ‘Alone With You’, see them perform live! on Countdown here:

Shooting down** the difficulties with ‘fixed’ testamentary trust wills

As mentioned in last week’s post, it is possible to gain access to the excepted trust income provisions under the Tax Act where a will provides for the assets to be held on trust for infant children until they reach a certain age.

It is important to note however that, as compared a comprehensive testamentary discretionary trust, there can be a number of difficulties with the more basic approach including:

1. The assets of the trust will normally pass absolutely to the child beneficiaries on them attaining a certain age. Often this age will automatically be 18.
2. There is no real flexibility in terms of distributions of income or capital at any point during the structure. This can cause a number of difficulties particularly in relation to asset protection and tax planning.
3. The structure is very inflexible in terms of future estate and succession planning objectives and requires that the child beneficiaries implement comprehensive estate plans for themselves as soon as they gain entitlement to the assets.

As usual, please make contact if you would like access to any of the content mentioned in this post.

** For the trainspotters, the title of today's post is riffed from the Stone Roses song ‘Shoot you down’.

View here:

Shining a light** on ‘fixed’ Testamentary trust wills

‘Simple’ or ‘I love you’ wills are normally a relatively straightforward document and traditionally provide for assets to be gifted directly to a surviving spouse and then if not to the children of the relationship on them reaching a certain age (e.g. 18, 21 or 25).

One issue that often comes up in relation to this type of will is whether the ‘excepted trust income provisions’ under the Tax Act can be accessed. These provisions allow children to be taxed at adult rates for income distributed to them via a deceased estate.

In very broad terms, the excepted trust income provisions can only be accessed via this type of will during the period that the infant children of the deceased (and, in particular, not grandchildren) remain under the age of 18.

Next week’s post will explore some of the difficulties with this type of will as compared to more comprehensive testamentary trust arrangements.

As usual, please make contact if you would like access to any of the content mentioned in this post.

** For the trainspotters, the title of today's post is riffed from the Rolling Stones song ‘Shine a light’.

View here: